Fairfield West goes wild
Extreme Makeover: Home edition
2008 homecomings
Home > Blogs > Sir Critic on Cinema > Archives > 2008 > June > 20 > Entry
Get reasonably Smart - and funny
Try this for a new Get Smart catchphrase - “Hit it by THAT much!”
I know, it’s supposed to say “Missed it by THAT much!” But the new movie does the opposite. Instead of just missing, it just hits. Get Smart is solidly entertaining, but it could have been funnier.
My memories of the TV show are pretty fuzzy, but as best I can tell, this movie isn’t exactly the 1960s series writ large. In addition to being a spy spoof, the movie is also a James Bond adventure - and that approach turns out to be a mixed bag.
Maxwell Smart (Steve Carell) is an analyst for the spy agency CONTROL who longs to be a field agent. He gets his chance when the enemy agency KAOS hatches a plot to detonate a bomb in Los Angeles. His partner is Agent 99 (Anne Hathaway), who’s none too pleased to be working with an inexperienced klutz. Of course, like so many couples, what starts as animosity ends in amour.
Combining the zany antics of the TV show with the high octane of a 007 movie makes sense on paper, but on film it’s a bit of mess because comedy director Peter Segal (Tommy Boy, 50 First Dates) isn’t skilled with action scenes. He stages a good sequence that’s a nod to the one great scene in Moonraker, the skydiving chase. On the whole, though, the fights and pursuits are a blurry mess, marred by overediting and too many close-ups.
As for the comedy, it’s uneven. Segal makes too many of the jokes obvious, and some are flat-out misfires, like the revelation that Max was once grossly overweight. However, there are some hilarious scenes, such as the escape through a laser-filled room, which 99 navigates quite successfully and Max … doesn’t. A dance-off between the two leads gets increasingly ridiculous, and increasingly funny.
Standout scenes like these work because of the great cast. More than anything else, the actors, especially Carell and Hathaway, keep Get Smart afloat.
Carell doesn’t take the easy way out, playing Max simply as a lovable screw-up. Max is also a bit full of himself, but with good reason - he knows he can be a good field agent, and Carell sells Max’s increasing confidence very well. Hathaway has never had a sexier part. She enlivens every movie she’s in, and if she’s not already on the A-list where she belongs, Get Smart will put her there permanently.
Most of the supporting players are fun too. Alan Arkin is perfect as the put-upon chief, and Dwayne Johnson has fun with his image playing an impossibly perfect agent. Casting Masi Osaka from Heroes as a tech nerd is particularly inspired. Only Terence Stamp draws the short straw, playing a villain who isn’t given enough to do.
As much as I enjoyed Get Smart, I still found myself wishing the movie were as funny as its ads, or as good as its cast. Maybe for the sequel, the producers ought to let the marketing people take a crack at the script.
GRADE: B
Permalink | Comments (2) | Post your comment | Categories: Reviews
Comments
By Rich
June 22, 2008 4:18 PM | Link to this
My wife and I both agree with Barb’s earlier comment — this movie is far better than average. While Sir Critic’s comment (…the fights and pursuits are a blurry mess, marred by overediting and too many close-ups) is exactly right, the overall movie is entertaining and very funny. We have to remember that a half-hour comedy show is going to be a little plot-deficient compared to a full-length movie; put another way, a movie MUST have greater plot than a half-hour sitcom, even if it risks becoming a watered-down James Bond or Mission Impossible. The supporting characters in the movie are uniformly amusing — a good time was had by nearly all in the theatre WE attended! Many laugh-out-loud moments, which is a rare thing these days.By Barb =:)
June 20, 2008 8:04 PM | Link to this
I just saw this movie and have to say I thoroughly enjoyed it. I was laughing out loud all the way through, as were all the people I saw in the theater. MUCH more funny than most critics have said. The casting was right on. The TV show was campier, but the movie is funny. Definitely worth a trip to the theater, and I don’t say that too much anymore.